Black head coaches rare at top tier of college basketball
Craig Meyer/Pittsburgh Post-Gazette Associated Press | 11/15/2019, 6 a.m.
PITTSBURGH Jeff Capel carries a measure of gratitude with him every time he paces the sideline at Petersen Events Center.
As he enters his second season as Pitt’s basketball coach, he thinks of his late father who went from a volunteer JV high school coach to head coach of an NCAA tournament team in fewer than 20 years. He thinks of John Thompson and Nolan Richardson, national championship-winning coaches who doubled as aspirational figures. He thinks of all the other black coaches who never reached those same heights, but whose achievements helped make his story possible.
“I’m here because of my dad and because of the guys I just mentioned, because of their shoulders and because of the things they did to open up the door,” Coach Capel said.
Now, at age 44 and in his 11th season as a Division I head coach, a future that once seemed so boundless for men like him seems dimmer.
Pitt’s game Wednesday against Florida State wasn’t only going to be unusual because it’s the rare conference matchup to open a season; it’s also because each team is led by a black coach, with Coach Capel on one bench and Leonard Hamilton on the other. In a sport in which a majority of assistant coaches and an overwhelming majority of the scholarship players are black, the number of black head coaches lags behind.
Of the 75 programs in college basketball’s six major conferences, only 14 have a black head coach (18.7 percent). If the count is limited to the so-called Power Five leagues, eliminating the Big East and its five black head coaches, that number dips to 13.8 percent. The percentage of black head coaches in those six conferences is lower now than it was during the 1996-97 season, when Coach Capel was a senior at Duke University.
To those in the sport, particularly those most affected by it, it stands as a glaring and maddeningly resilient set of numbers that, even when they prompt discussion, has seldom led to change.
“As long as this continues to go on, you’re always going to have coaches who are getting left out and are not getting those opportuni- ties,” said LeVelle Moton, head coach at North Carolina Central. “It’s heartbreaking, man. It’s really heartbreaking.”
Shortage at the top
The statistics that illustrate the realities for black college basketball coaches are most no- ticeable at the top levels of the sport.
Across all of Division I men’s basketball (353 schools), 29.2 percent of head coaches are black. It’s a much higher percentage than it is in the major conferences, but when coaches at black colleges and universities (HBCUs) are removed from the equation, that number falls to 24.1 percent.
After an offseason in which four black head coaches were fired in the six major conferences, the Pac-12 doesn’t have a single black coach. When Michigan tapped former standout Juwan Howard as its new coach in May, he became the first black head coach hired by a Big Ten program since 2007.
These gaps are happening while 78.9 percent of the major conference scholarship players are black, creating a disconnect.
“It’s a great concern,” said Jim Haney, executive director of the National Association of Basketball Coaches (NABC). “We know we have quality people capable of being head coaches. One can say ‘Are coaches of color getting opportunities?’ You would clearly say the percentages suggest no.”
It’s not as if the low number of black head coaches is the product of a shallow talent pool, either. At Division I programs, 50.1 percent of assistant coaches are black, and even when assistants from HBCUs aren’t included, that number is still at 47.6 percent.
“More people need to understand this — it can’t be that we can play the game and our assistants can recruit the game, but we can’t ask head coaches at the highest level to coach the game,” said Ron Hunter, head coach at Tulane University and a former NABC president.
What’s most distressing to some in the industry is that the share of head coaches who are black has fallen significantly in the past 15 years.
As far back as the 1997-98 season, exactly one-quarter of major conference head coaches were black, a group including Tubby Smith, who led the University of Kentucky to a national championship that year. That figure was above 30 percent from 2000 to 2006, peaking at 33.8 percent during the 2004-05 season. In each of the past six seasons, however, it hasn’t been higher than 21.3 percent, sinking as low as 16 percent during the 2016-17 campaign.
“I’ve been disappointed and confused with the whole process,” Hamilton said. “I’ve been searching, trying to figure out how we come to some resolution on where we go from here.”
A look at leadership
The problem, as anyone will carefully explain, is complex. It is a creation of a litany of factors, variables that extend beyond pres- ent circumstances and the gyms in which the games are played.
The reason that’s easiest to understand, or is at least the most quantifiable, is that a lack of diversity among coaches is the byproduct of a lack of diversity in leadership in athletic departments and at universities. At Division I schools, 15.6 percent of athletic directors are black, a number that falls to 10 percent at non-HBCUs. In the major conferences, 13.3 percent of athletic directors are black. Only one university president in those leagues, Ohio State’s Michael V. Drake, is black.
“That’s the worst report card we issue every year in terms of grades. The only one that really has Fs in it is the D-I leadership report,” said Richard Lapchick, director of The Institute for Diversity and Ethics in Sport at the University of Central Florida. “If it’s a bunch of white guys making decisions, it might not necessarily be that they’re racist, but it might mean that they just don’t know any people that don’t look like or think like them.”
The dissolution of the Black Coaches Associa- tion (BCA), a nonprofit organization dedicated to fostering the growth of minorities in coaching, has also played a prominent part in the current predicament. For years, the BCA — with men such as Georgetown’s Thompson, Arkansas’ Richardson and Temple’s John Chaney serving as its face — wielded significant power, apply- ing pressure on the powers-that-be to improve hiring practices, as well as helping educate black coaches and prepare them for the hiring process. Its influence was one reason why mi- nority coaching percentages were once so high. Its absence has created a vacuum.
“It kept a balance,” said Perry Clark, a former head coach at Tulane and Miami who is now an assistant coach at South Carolina. “It allowed us to have a voice in that arena.”
A glass ceiling
Even 14 years removed from it, Coach Capel will never forget the conversation.
Shortly before his final season at Virginia Commonwealth in 2005, Coach
Capel was an assistant for the United States’ team in the World University Games in Izmir, Turkey, where he wrote a series of blog entries that appeared on VCU’s website detailing the experience. While in his office one day after he returned home, someone who worked at the university complimented the pieces and asked who wrote them for him.
When Coach Capel replied it was him, the other person was incredulous, asking again who wrote them.
“I was like ‘I did graduate from Duke, man,’ ” Coach Capel said. “I don’t know if a white coach would have gotten that.”
His experience is hardly unique. For many black coaches interviewed for this story, their time in the profession has shown them that, merely because of the color of their skin, they’re liable to be viewed a certain way, even if there’s no malicious intent behind it.
It’s perhaps most evident in the gulf between the percentage of black assistants and black head coaches in the Power Five conferences and Big East. In those leagues, 58.7 percent of assistant coaches are black, more than three times as high as the 18.7 percent of head coaches who are black. Each of the 75 programs in those conferences has at least one black assistant.
That gap illustrates what many black coaches see as a widely held view that they’re often best-suited as recruiters. When Coach Capel was approached by Duke in 2011 to be an assistant following his firing as head coach at Oklahoma, he said he didn’t want to be brought in only to be what he dubbed “The Black Recruiter.”
“In some peoples’ minds, there’s a difference between relating to players and running a program,” Clark said.
That distinction can lead to a label that can stunt career advancement, serving as a glass ceiling of sorts.
“It can be crippling,” Coach Capel said.
That all-too-common portrayal of black coaches was reinforced by the FBI investigation into corruption in college basketball. Rick Pitino, a white head coach, was fired after his Louis- ville program was implicated, but among the 10 people arrested in 2017 when the investigation was revealed to the public were four assistant coaches — Emanuel “Book” Richardson, Chuck Person, Tony Bland and Lamont Evans — all of whom are black.
“That bothered me,” Hunter said. “Those four guys weren’t the guys that caused the issues that we’ve got in this business. But what came out of it were four African-Americans that had to go to trial and that became the face of college basketball. That was one of the low points I’ve had in this business.”
“They’re the face of it,” said Stan Heath, a former head coach at Arkansas and South Florida. “They’re the scapegoat of it. It just doesn’t smell right.”
Nearly one-quarter of the 103 black Division I coaches are at HBCUs, where they face stifling elements of their own. When Coach Capel first got into coaching, his father, a graduate of an HBCU who coached at HBCUs for years, told him not to take a job at an HBCU because it’s hard, if not impossible, to move up to a bigger program. In the past 20 years, only four black coaches have gone directly from an HBCU to a predominantly white Division I institution.
At schools in smaller leagues, some of whom are severely limited in their resources, advancement in the college basketball hierarchy can be difficult.
“You do get pigeonholed,” said
Moton, who has led North Carolina Central to three consecutive NCAA tournaments. “It’s almost like Major League Baseball and then the Negro Leagues. It’s Satchel Paige and Josh Gibson and Cool Papa Bell and Jackie Robinson. They’re over here and everyone else is pretty much over there. They’re not invited to the party.”
Eddie Robinson Rule?
For years, Lapchick and organizations like the National Association for Coaching Equity & Development have advocated for what they call the Eddie Robinson Rule. Named after the iconic Grambling football coach, the measure would require schools to interview at least one minority candidate for any head-coaching or leadership position before settling on a final hire. In spirit and practice, it’s similar to the Rooney Rule in the NFL.
The NCAA has said that it, as a nonprofit and voluntary member association, can’t legally adopt such a rule. Instead, it asked members to sign a pledge committing to promoting diversity and gender equity. According to the NCAA’s website, 290 Division I school presidents have signed it, but a handful of notable schools, such as Notre Dame and Boston College, haven’t. More than three years after the pledge’s introduction, minority representation among college basketball coaches, athletic directors and college football coaches (only 10.8percent of Football Bowl Subdivision coaches are black) remains low.
In Oregon, which has required state schools to interview candidates of color, Lapchick sees an example of how the Eddie Robinson Rule could work effectively, but it also makes him wonder why more states haven’t taken a similar approach.
“Unless we change the hiring practices, we’re going to end up with the same type of figures deep into the future,” Lapchick said.
Short of anything codified, most prescriptions are tied to broader changes in culture and mindsets, with the hope that such shifts would lead to substantive change.
Ohio State athletic director Gene Smith, one of 10 black people in the major confer- ences to hold such a position, thinks back to his time at Arizona State, when the Pac-10 (now Pac-12) would host sessions in which minority coaches could connect with athletic administrators. He believes similar events and a more concerted effort from conferences could improve matters.
“To me, it’s those moments where an AD can have 20 minutes in a casual environment back in the day, when Shaka (Smart) was coming through or an Ed Cooley,” Smith said. “You’d have a chance to just connect and say ‘OK, if I ever have an opening, that guy is going to be on my list.’ To me, that’s an effort that needs to be more intentional, broader and deeper.”